California Sex Worker Convicted of Manslaughter in Shooting Incident
In a case that has captured national attention, Leniyah Butler, a 21-year-old sex worker, has been found guilty of manslaughter following the fatal shooting of a client in San Francisco. The incident occurred in November 2023 when Butler allegedly shot Hamza Walupupu, 32, in response to his demand for a refund after a sexual act was performed.
Incident Overview
Reports indicate that the confrontation began when Walupupu became upset after Butler revealed her transgender identity. This revelation reportedly contributed to escalating tensions between the two, resulting in the fatal shooting in the Presidio district of the city.
Details of the Altercation
Court documents detail that Butler felt endangered when Walupupu drove her away from the original location where they had met. She expressed feeling “out of her element” due to the distance from her known surroundings, heightening her sense of vulnerability during the encounter.
Butler’s Defense and Statement
In her defense, Butler claimed to police, “I apologize to anyone I hurt, but my life was in danger, and I felt like I had to defend myself in that moment or it would have been me.” However, she added, “I don’t think I should say sorry to nobody because… I don’t feel sorry for smoking him.” These statements have been scrutinized during the trial and have become significant points of discussion.
Aftermath and Evidence Tampering
Following the incident, Butler reportedly fled the scene, taking Walupupu’s car and attempting to eliminate evidence linked to the crime, including the weapon used in the shooting. The prosecution presented this behavior as indicative of her consciousness of guilt.
Mother’s Recorded Conversation
Compounding the case against her, a recorded conversation with Butler’s mother surfaced, where she allegedly stated that Walupupu “deserved to be killed.” This admission played a crucial role in how the jury perceived her intent and state of mind at the time of the incident.
Legal Consequences
Currently in custody, Butler is set to be sentenced on June 27, 2025. Legal experts suggest that she faces a potential sentence of 17 years, alongside a substantial fine of $250,000 as stipulated by the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Northern District of California.
Community Reactions and Closing Thoughts
This case has sparked discussions on the safety and regulation of sex work, particularly concerning issues surrounding violence, transgender rights, and legal protections for sex workers. As the sentencing date approaches, the implications of this case may resonate beyond the courtroom, influencing ongoing dialogues about these critical social issues.
